Analytical Essay The Trouble With Wilderness

For Didion, a notebook was a place to remember how it felt to be her. Our notebooks are the building block of our writerly lives, and I encourage students to use their notebooks beyond our classroom walls.Much has already been written about the limitations of the 5-paragraph essay form.In particular, I’d suggest looking up what college educators Paul Thomas and John Warner have written on the topic. First, I explain, we’ll be keeping our own notebooks throughout the year. “I like to start the year with ‘On Keeping a Notebook’ for a few different reasons,” I tell the thesis statement always goes at the end of the introduction, how thesis statements need three reasons, how first person isn’t allowed in formal essays, how paragraphs are 6-8 sentences long, and on and on. It’s about getting closer—through repeated observation, approximation, and experimentation—to a deeper understanding of the world around us.

It seems like a good compromise: we’ll keep the 5-paragraph essay and just add other types of writing.Shouldn’t that be how we approach writing, how we frame essays?As a way of getting to because of three very specific reasons outlined in a thesis statement found at the end of an introduction.When I ask a follow-up, “What’s the difference between Didion’s essay and the ones you just described? During our discussion, I admit to students that I’ve been guilty of (over)teaching the 5-paragraph essay.” a student says, not-so-quietly, “It’s well-written.” His classmates laugh. I also tell them, however, that the longer I teach, the more I realize that some of my former teaching practices weren’t always best practices, though I didn’t realize it at the time (former students: my apologies). Some students seem surprised to hear a teacher admit such a thing, but it’s all about having growth mindset, right?Ebarvia.” (Side note: Talking about myself—or my teacher-self—in the third person is becoming habit, I fear. We also read Didion’s essay because it’s simply a beautiful piece of writing. And yes, her essay has an intro, body, and conclusion.I find that many high school students often need to be reminded that English is a language , the first hand goes up. Encouraged, more students offer responses: “Structured.” “Rigid.” “Intro, body, and conclusion.” “Thesis statement.” “Argumentative.” “Research.” “Formal.” “School assignment.” I then ask, “How much of what you just said describes Didion’s essay? But Didion’s essay is neitherfive paragraphs, nor is it rigid. It uses a first-person point-of-view, it shifts and moves, wonders and supposes.My own inexperience in teaching students to write sans formula was reflected in the writing they produced. A band-aid may be an easier short-term solution, but it often only covers up the real problem.In the United States, we’ve done a good job at doing the wrong things better, Richardson pointed out. It’s one of those classes that—less than a month into the school year—has already started to feel like a writing community. My AP Lang class and I are in the midst of finishing up our discussion of Joan Didion’s wonderful essay, “On Keeping a Notebook.” It’s a relatively small class: twenty-one mostly juniors who come together at the end of each day to read, write, talk, laugh, and yes, learn.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

One thought on “Analytical Essay The Trouble With Wilderness”

  1. It is challenging task, an experienced with the cultural conflicts that would lead to shunning in case an Amish youth decline from their cultural practices to indulge in the non-Amish practices after denouncing their personal decision to be baptized and walk in accordance with the Amish culture (Hostetler, 1993).