Essay Questions On Personal Identity Essays On Types Of Pollution

In the passage from Book IV quoted above, Locke is telling us that both possibilities, thinking matter and immaterial thinking substance, are beyond our comprehension and requires in either case God to add the powers of perception and thought to matter or to the immaterial substance—which is then joined to the fitly disposed matter.

The thinking matter hypothesis disturbed a number of Locke’s early critics (and some later ones).

The memories of my current conscious self are completely absent during the time period that I was asleep (Reid 370).

My argument demonstrates that Locke’s theory of personal identity is not possible. If Locke’s theory is true, then I am not the same person that I was while I was sleeping last night. I am the same person I was while I was sleeping last night. This argument is valid because it follows the Modus Tollens form.

______________________________________________________________________________ 3. If the two premises are true, the conclusion has to be true.

By denying the consequent of the first premise, it is impossible for the antecedent to be true.

He writes: Locke makes a distinction between what we can know and propositions that are only probable.

In the passage quoted above he is telling us that we may never be able to know whether dualist or materialist theories of mind are true.

In this supplement, we consider some of the most interesting and controversial claims that Locke makes in the Philosophy of Mind.

Indeed, it would seem that his suggestion in IV.3.6 and his adoption of the principle in IV.10.9 amount to a contradiction. In another part of the discussion of thinking matter, he writes: For I see no contradiction in it, that the first Eternal Thinking Being, should, if he pleased, give to certain systems of created, senseless matter, put together as he thinks fit, some degree of sense, perception and thought: Though I think as I have prove, Lib IV c.10th it is no less a contradiction to suppose matter (which is in its own nature void of sense and thought) should be that eternal first thinking Being.

What Certainty of knowledge can anyone have that some perceptions, such as v.g.

In his recent book, and other works, including his Correspondence with Bishop Stillingfleet suggest that Locke is trying to show that a weak form of materialism is a plausible candidate in the Philosophy of Mind (Jolley 2015: 8).

What Jolley has in mind is form of materialism that is compatible with a dualism of properties (Jolley 2015: 11–12).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

One thought on “Essay Questions On Personal Identity”